Article
news flash
The Sherlock Episode That Ruined The Show Forever
2024/06/24

ADVERTISEMENT

Ah, the conundrum that BBC’s "Sherlock" fans still wrestle with—how did a single episode turn a celebrated series into a contentious debate among fans? Some say it was a masterstroke of storytelling; others argue it was the beginning of the end. Let’s dive into the episode that divided an otherwise unified fandom.

Season 3's Thorn in the Side: "His Last Vow"

Season 3's "His Last Vow" was intended to be a rollercoaster of emotions, revelations, and mind-bending twists. The show had been riding high on critical acclaim and a fervent fanbase, bolstered by the impeccable performances of Benedict Cumberbatch as Sherlock Holmes and Martin Freeman as Dr.

ADVERTISEMENT

John Watson. However, this particular episode elicited a storm of controversy.

In the episode, Sherlock confronts the nefarious media mogul Charles Augustus Magnussen, played with chilling precision by Lars Mikkelsen. Unlike earlier villains, Magnussen was less about physical threats and more about psychological manipulation—a modern adversary rooted in the dirty secrets of the digital age. Sherlock's decision to fatally shoot Magnussen at the episode's climax took many by surprise.

ADVERTISEMENT

Magnussen vs. Moriarty: A Villain Miscast?

For many fans, Magnussen lacked the sheer charisma and intellectual rivalry that Moriarty brought to the table. Moriarty, portrayed by Andrew Scott, was the perfect nemesis—a mix of malevolence and wit that kept viewers on the edge of their seats. On the other hand, Magnussen’s subtle, almost mundane evil didn’t seem to carry the same weight.

Molly Hooper’s reaction encapsulated what many fans felt.

The article is not finished. Click on the next page to continue.

ADVERTISEMENT

8 Reasons A Sherlock Movie Would Be Better Than Season 5 After The Cumberbatch Show's Fall From Grace
2024/06/24
Prison Break Season 6 : Release Date, Plot & Cast, Renewed On Hulu?
2024/06/24
Wentworth Miller Exits Prison Break Reboot, Is Done Playing Straight Characters
2024/06/24
NFL Legend’s Hot Take About Michael Jordan’s Shoes Gets a Seal of Approval from Shannon Sharpe
2024/04/25
Michael Jordan Unveiling Jordan Brand 27 Years Before Earning $330 Million From It Resurfaces
2024/04/25
LeBron James’ Presence Keeps Jamal Crawford from Picking Denver Nuggets as the Winners of First Round
2024/04/25
Following A Heartbreaking Loss, LeBron James Injury Status For Lakers-Nuggets Game 3 May Prove to Be Worrisome For LA Fans
2024/04/25
“I Was Kind Of Jealous Of Him”: LeBron James’ Power In Cleveland Befuddled Shaquille O’Neal
2024/04/25
“Wet willies, cheek kisses, maybe a few wedgies”: Cramer pumped for Welsh clubmate reunion | Latest Rugby News | RUGBY.com.au
2024/04/25
Wonderkid picks Australian Rugby over mega-money code-switch
2024/04/25
Rugby World Cup winner ready for scrum battle in star-studded derby
2024/04/25
Rugby star suffers wardrobe malfunction as fans spot his 'Barbie girl' hotpants
2024/04/25
Rugby World Cup 2023 confirmed as most viewed rugby event of all time
2024/04/25
Wallabies assistant blames Super Rugby for World Cup capitulation
2024/04/25
All Blacks coach blasts ‘disgusting’ abuse in wake of World Rugby report
2024/04/25
Super Rugby Pacific 2024 Teams: All the team news for Round Seven
2024/04/25
Scott Robertson hailed for appointing New Zealand’s ‘great rugby thinker’
2024/04/25
Perenara hunting Super Rugby record as Blackadder gives embattled Crusaders boost
2024/04/25
The Eddie Jones legacy and what’s next for the Wallabies | Latest Rugby News | RUGBY.com.au
2024/04/25
'Honoured to get the call' - Wales great excited by Super Rugby challenge
2024/04/25